Should I Try to Get My Ex Back? An Honest Way to Decide
Not a set of tactics. A fair way to decide that respects her choice and takes your own life seriously.

Video version: The honest way to decide about getting her back
Coming soon. Everything in the video is in the written guide below.
Should I try to get my ex back? For most men a few weeks out, the honest answer is no, not yet, and probably not at all. Before you decide, answer four questions on paper, hold no-contact for 30 days, and check whether you miss her or miss not being alone. Then put the energy back into your own life.
"Part of me still wants to try to win her back."
It flares up after a good memory, or when a friend says "she might come round, you know". Suddenly you're planning again: what you'd say, how you'd show her you've changed.
An honest decision that respects her choice, and the energy you were spending on getting her back put into your own life instead.
Why the hope is so hard to switch off
Hope feels better than grief. While there's a plan to win her back, the loss isn't final yet. You're not someone who's been left. You're someone with a project.
That's why the hope can be so sticky. It protects you from the full weight of the ending. But it also holds you in place. You can't fully grieve something you're still trying to get back, so the recovery stalls.
The pillar guide on how to get closure after a breakup explains why we don't teach win-back tactics. This post is about making the decision itself, honestly, so it stops hanging over every day.
Four questions to answer before "should I try to get my ex back"
Write the answers down. Thinking them through in bed doesn't count.
- What has she actually said? Her words, not your interpretation of a look or a story view. If she said "it's over", that's the starting point.
- What ended it, and what has changed? List the real reasons, then what's different now on both sides. "I miss her more" isn't a change.
- What, specifically, would be different next time? Not "we'd try harder". What would each of you do differently, starting which week?
- Is it her I miss, or not being alone? Picture a different kind, attractive person who liked you. If the pull drops a lot, it's loneliness.
If question one says "over" and question two says "nothing has changed", you have your answer, even if it hurts.
The 30-day hold
Don't decide anything while the hope is at its loudest. Give yourself a fixed decision date.
- Write today's date and a decision date 30 days from now on a card.
- Hold full no-contact for those 30 days: no messages, no checking, no asking friends about her.
- Put the energy into one project of your own, such as training, a course or a trip.
- Answer the four questions again on the decision date, in daylight.
- Talk your answers through with one person you trust who knew you both.
- Write your decision in one sentence and act on it calmly.
Why 30 days
A few weeks of no-contact lets the first rush settle. Sleep improves, the checking habit weakens and you start to see her more clearly. Many men find the question has quietly answered itself by the decision date.
If it hasn't, you're at least deciding from a steadier place, not from a 1 a.m. surge of hope.
Where the energy goes
Hope burns a lot of energy: planning, rehearsing, watching for signs. Give it a job. Something with a number attached works best, like a 5k time, a savings target or a trip booked for spring. That energy was always yours.
The decision note: copy this
Use it on your decision date.
What she has said: ...
What ended it: ...
What has really changed since: ...
What would be different, specifically: ...
Do I miss her, or being with someone? ...
My decision, in one sentence: ...
And when a friend says she might come round, you can answer:
"Maybe, maybe not. I'm not building my life around that. I'm focusing on me for now."
Ben and the 30-day card
Ben, 35, teaches history at a secondary school in Sheffield. His partner of six years ended it in August. In September a friend told him she "seemed sad", and Ben spent a week planning a long message about how he'd changed. Instead he wrote a 30-day card and started training for a half marathon. On day 30 he answered the four questions. She'd said "it's over" twice. The main reason, wanting different things about children, hadn't changed. His one sentence was: "I love her, and I'm letting her go." He still has hard days. He no longer spends them planning.
Still in love with my ex: what that does and doesn't mean
Being still in love with my ex is something many men say with shame, as if it's weakness. It isn't. Love doesn't switch off because a relationship ended. It fades on its own schedule, usually faster once you stop feeding it.
What the feeling doesn't do is answer the question. You can love someone and accept that it's over. That's often what respect her decision looks like in practice: holding both at once.
If you're wondering how to know if you should give up on your ex, look at actions, not feelings. Has she said it's over? Has she gone quiet, or started seeing someone? Our guide on when your ex moved on quickly helps if that last one has already happened.
If the relationship involved fear or control
This test assumes a relationship that was safe. If she threatened you, controlled your money or movements, hurt you, or you felt afraid of her, don't use these questions to plan a way back or a meeting to talk it through. Talk to someone outside the relationship first: in the US, the National Domestic Violence Hotline (call 1-800-799-7233 or text START to 88788; in the UK, the National Domestic Abuse Helpline on 0808 2000 247 or the Men's Advice Line on 0808 801 0327) supports men too; elsewhere, contact local domestic abuse services. If you're in danger, call emergency services.
Mistakes that keep you waiting
- Running tactics. Jealousy plays, strategic silence and "accidental" meetings don't respect her decision, and they keep you stuck.
- Deciding from the highlight reel. If you're mostly remembering the good times, read only remember the good times with your ex before deciding.
- Using "closure" as cover for a win-back attempt. If the real hope behind "I just want to understand" is reconciliation, be honest with yourself about it. See why did she leave me.
- Treating a reply as a sign. A polite answer to a practical message is politeness, not an opening.
Not sure whether this question, or something else, is holding you back most? The two-minute Recovery Score quiz points to where to focus first.
- You've written answers to the four questions, not just thought about them.
- You've held no-contact for the 30 days or are on track to.
- One project of your own is getting the energy the hope was using.
- You have a decision in one sentence and feel steadier for having it.
- If you're still undecided after 30 days, take it to a trusted friend or a counsellor rather than to her.
Key takeaways
- Hope feels better than grief, which is why it's sticky.
- Answer four questions on paper: what she said, what changed, what would differ, her or loneliness.
- Hold a 30-day decision date with full no-contact.
- Put the energy into one project with a number attached.
- You can love her and still let her go.
Questions people ask
Should I try to get my ex back if I'm still in love with her?
Being still in love with her is a real feeling, but it isn't enough on its own. A relationship needs both people to want it and a realistic reason to believe it would go differently. If she has clearly said it's over and nothing important has changed, trying to win her back usually delays your recovery. Love can fade on its own time.
How do you know if you should give up on your ex?
Strong signs it's time to let go: she has clearly said she doesn't want to get back together, she's stopped contact or started seeing someone, the reasons it ended are still unchanged, or you're mainly lonely rather than missing her specifically. Giving up on her isn't giving up on yourself. It frees the energy for your own life.
Do 'get your ex back' tactics work?
Most popular tactics rely on manipulation, such as making her jealous, using silence as a strategy or engineering accidental meetings. They don't respect her decision, and even when they produce contact, the original problems are usually still there. Any genuine reconciliation starts with two people freely choosing it, not with one person running a plan on the other.
What if my ex wants to get back together?
Don't decide in the moment. Thank her, say you need time to think, and give yourself at least a week. Look at what ended it, what's actually changed on both sides and whether you'd be choosing her or choosing relief from loneliness. Talk it through with someone you trust and decide in daylight, not late at night.

Free survival kit
Hold steady for the 30 days before you decide
In 30 minutes you finish with a phone that stops ambushing you, a 20-minute drill for every urge, calm replies ready if she gets in touch and a simple plan for your next seven days.


