Why You Only Remember the Good Times With Your Ex, and How to See It Whole

Your memory is cutting a trailer: best scenes, no boring bits, a great soundtrack. The fix is to watch the whole film, once, on paper.

A young man sits on a sofa holding an old printed holiday photo, looking at it thoughtfully in soft afternoon light

Video version: The highlight reel your memory plays after a breakup

Coming soon. Everything in the video is in the written guide below.

If your head keeps saying "I only remember the good times with my ex", you're seeing a highlight reel, not the relationship. Memory after a loss favours the peaks and quietly drops the friction. The fix isn't to trash her. It's to rewatch the whole film once, on paper, so the trailer loses its pull.

Sound familiar?

"I only remember the good times now, and I can't understand why I let it end."

It usually starts with something specific: an old photo, the date of a trip, a song from a road holiday. Suddenly the relationship looks perfect and the ending looks like a mistake.

Your desired outcome

You can see the whole relationship, good and bad, side by side, so the highlight reel loses its pull and you stop asking why you let it end.

Why memory edits in her favour

This effect is often called euphoric recall. When you lose something, your mind reaches for the best of it. The holiday in Crete, the first months, the night you laughed until 3 a.m. Those are vivid, emotional memories, so they surface first.

The ordinary stuff fades. The Sunday evenings in separate rooms. The same argument about her friends every other week. The way you'd stopped really talking. None of it was dramatic, so none of it got stored as a story.

Grief adds to it. When you're lonely, your mind goes looking for comfort, and the best memories are the most comforting. Then the photos on your phone, curated to show only good days, confirm the edit. It's also why grief waves after a breakup so often start with a photo.

The pillar guide on how to get closure after a breakup uses a four-part letter covering gratitude, hurt, responsibility and letting go. This post zooms in on one piece: undoing the edit, so the gratitude part doesn't swallow everything else.

"I only remember the good times with my ex": watch the full film

  1. Notice the reel starting and say "trailer" to yourself, so you know what you're watching.
  2. Pick the one highlight that pulls hardest, such as a trip, a birthday or the first summer.
  3. Write the full scene: the day before, the highlight itself, and the week after.
  4. List ten ordinary low points from the last year, with no insults, just what happened.
  5. Read the full film, not the photos, whenever the reel plays.
  6. Check your version with one friend who saw the relationship up close.

Writing the scene around the highlight

Most highlights look different with the frame widened. The holiday was wonderful, and the week before you'd talked about splitting up. The birthday was great, and you drove home in silence.

You're not trying to ruin the memory. Both things were true. The goal is to let your mind hold both at once, which is what seeing it whole means.

The ten ordinary low points

These aren't the worst moments. They're the everyday ones. "She went to bed at nine most nights and I stayed up gaming." "We hadn't had a proper conversation about the future in a year." "I felt lonely sitting next to her." Write them plainly, the way you'd describe weather.

If you can't think of ten, think about specific days of the week. What did a normal Tuesday look like in the last six months?

Copy these full-film prompts

Use them as headings on a page and fill in each one.

"The highlight I keep replaying is..."

"The week before it, what was really going on was..."

"The week after it, things were..."

"A normal Tuesday in our last six months looked like..."

"Something I stopped saying to her was..."

"The reasons it ended, in her words and in mine, were..."

Keep the page somewhere you can find it when an anniversary or a photo sets off the reel.

Illustrative example

Ollie and the Crete photos

Ollie, 28, is a graphic designer in Brighton. His girlfriend of four years ended it in the spring. In September his phone showed him "two years ago today" photos from Crete, and he spent a week convinced he'd thrown away the best thing in his life. He wrote the full film for Crete. The week before, they'd argued about moving cities. The week after, she'd booked a weekend away without him. His ten low points took forty minutes. He showed the page to his brother, who added two more. Ollie still loves the Crete photos. He no longer thinks they're the whole story.

Romanticising my ex vs. respecting what was good

There's a trap on the other side too. Some men swing from "she was perfect" to "she was awful", because anger feels easier than longing. That isn't seeing it whole either, and it rarely lasts.

The aim is a fair account. She was kind in specific ways and difficult in specific ways. You were too. The relationship had real good years and real reasons to end. When you can say that calmly, you've stopped romanticising my ex without needing to hate her.

Photos make the edit worse. While you're doing this work, turn off "memories" and move the albums out of sight. The free No-Contact Survival Kit walks you through that in about 15 minutes.

Common mistakes with the highlight reel

  • Rewatching the photos to test yourself. The photos are the trailer. You'll lose that test every time. Read the full film instead.
  • Overcorrecting into a hate list. Ten ordinary low points, plainly written, are more convincing to your mind than fifty insults.
  • Deciding anything during the reel. Anniversaries and lonely evenings are the worst time to judge the relationship. Wait for an ordinary afternoon.
  • Treating the reel as proof you should try again. If that question is loud, work through should you get your ex back before you act on it.
You'll know it's working when
  • You can name a highlight and, in the same breath, what was happening around it.
  • Your list of ordinary low points exists and feels fair, not bitter.
  • When a photo or date sets off the reel, you reach for the full film, not the album.
  • "Why did I let it end?" is shifting to "I can see why it ended".
  • If the reel is still constant after a few weeks, check whether photos, songs or her profiles are still feeding it, and clear those first.

Key takeaways

  • Euphoric recall plays the highlights and drops the everyday friction.
  • Rewatch the full film: the scene before and after each highlight.
  • Write ten ordinary low points plainly, without insults.
  • Seeing it whole means holding the good and the bad at once.
  • Don't decide anything about her while the reel is playing.

Questions people ask

Why do I only remember the good times with my ex?

After a loss, memory tends to favour the emotional high points, the holidays, the early months, the best nights, and lets ordinary friction fade. This is sometimes called euphoric recall. It's made stronger by grief, loneliness and reminders like photos and anniversaries. It doesn't mean the relationship was better than you thought; it means you're seeing an edited version.

Is it normal to romanticise an ex after a breakup?

Very normal. Romanticising an ex is one of the most common experiences after a breakup, especially in the first few months and around dates that meant something. It usually eases as you rebuild your own life and as you deliberately recall the whole relationship, including the parts that weren't working, rather than only the highlights.

How do I stop romanticising my ex?

Write down the whole story, not just the best scenes. For each highlight, add what happened the day before and after, and list ordinary low points such as recurring arguments or lonely evenings. Read that full version whenever the highlight reel starts. Reducing reminders like photo memories while you do this also helps a lot.

Does remembering the good times mean I should get back with her?

Not on its own. Good memories are real, and it's fine to value them. But a relationship ends for reasons that don't show up in the best photos. Before deciding anything, look at the whole picture, including why it ended and whether she wants it too. A decision made from the highlight reel is usually a decision made from loneliness.

Cover of the free No-Contact Survival Kit

Free survival kit

Stop old photos ambushing you while you do this work

In 30 minutes you finish with a phone that stops ambushing you, a 20-minute drill for every urge, calm replies ready if she gets in touch and a simple plan for your next seven days.

What happens next: an email asking you to reply VERIFY (it proves the address is yours), then your kit and 6 short emails over 12 days with free lessons, one of which describes our upcoming course and its waitlist. After that, at most one email a week. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy policy

Keep reading

More free guides